Welcome to A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza
A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza brings the taste of authentic New York pizza to Lancaster, PA with a variety of gourmet pizzas and Italian dishes. Customers rave about the delicious pies, with one reviewer proclaiming it as the best pizza in town. The owners, originally from Naples, Italy, ensure top-notch quality in every bite. From crispy fries to mouth-watering cheesesteaks, every dish is made with care and served with a smile. Experience a slice of the Big Apple right in Pennsylvania and discover why this local gem is a must-visit for pizza lovers.
A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Best pizza in town by far! A weekly go to for our family. The never disappoint. This is the best pizza I've had outside of New Jersey.
Wow. First time here! Delicious pie. Sauce & cheese just the best!! Positive & professional the moment you walk through the door. Great service with a smile. Can't wait to try other dishes!!
The absolutely best authentic New York pizza in Lancaster county I am an old New Yorker pizza snob and very particular of pizza Really nice hard working owners who grew up in Naples Italy'! Try it, you will NOT be disappointed Their other menu items as also excellent
Stopped in for a quick lunch. Best pizza ever!!! They offer so many gourmet pizzas but I went with plain cheese. So good. I wish I lived closer because I wouldn't order pizza elsewhere!
This place was a 10/10. I came here for lunch ordered a cheesesteak & fries and it did its thing. The wait wasn't too long despite it being busy. The workers were cool and there wasn't anything to complain about. The place is filled with things from NYC its pretty dope. The cheesesteak tasted amazing and the cheese they used on it was really good. The fries were cripsy and did what it did. I will definitely be coming back.
The pizza here is delicious - especially the Sicilian. This is our go to pizza place when visiting the Lancaster area. Their eggplant, meatballs, and pasta are also excellent. The owner and his staff are all so nice and welcoming.
First off, their food is absolutely delicious. I've had several different kinds of pizza, salads and subs. Definitely try their Grandma's pizza :) The service is always outstanding, every employee I've encountered is friendly & accommodating. They're quick and always will fix what doesn't seem right. The restaurant is clean and spacious.
Real good pizza! Mobster memorabilia everywhere and this joint can make a solid slice. We had the veggie and the Del Mar. In my opinion, the veg topped the seafood.
Location
-
1750 Oregon Pike Lancaster, PA 17601 Hotline: (717) 509-4444
A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza is a pizza gem located in Lancaster, PA, offering a mouthwatering array of New York-style pizzas, chicken wings, and Italian dishes. This casual restaurant provides a cozy atmosphere with outdoor seating and free Wi-Fi, making it a perfect spot for a quick lunch or a family dinner.
Their loyal customers rave about the authenticity and quality of their food. Laura L. describes it as the best pizza in town by far, while William H., a self-proclaimed New York pizza snob, praises it as the absolutely best authentic New York pizza in Lancaster county. With a variety of gourmet pizza options to choose from, even a simple cheese pizza impresses patrons like H L., who claims it's the best pizza ever.
But A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza isn't just about pizza. Customers like Shane S. have enjoyed their other menu items, such as the cheesesteak and fries, which he describes as a solid 10/10. The positive and professional service, along with the welcoming atmosphere filled with NYC memorabilia, adds to the overall dining experience.
So, if you're craving a slice of authentic New York pizza in Lancaster, look no further than A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza. Prepare to be delighted by their delicious pies, friendly service, and cozy ambiance.
